Wednesday, 23 October 2013


評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion 周永康

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

周永康:國際化淪大陸化 應減自資課程收生

「港大就非本地生研究生限額卻毫無節制,政府政策及大學管理層為求從內地人中覓取資源,不只塑造港大成為學店,
喪失高等學府純追求學術、尋求知識之姿,更有使「國際化」口號淪為『大陸化』之況。
……因學位及學府之名,甚得不少內地人鍾愛,當中多少純為吸納內地生牟利,質素惡劣,公眾學生無從得知。……『內地生人滿為患』,以致國際化有內地化之趨勢,不少亦可能是因自資課程而萌生之像。故要根治大學資源無從監察、質素低劣的課程不斷滋生、濫收以致資源緊張的坊間指責,公布有關自資課程的所有數字,以致適當調低有關課程收生限額,實在刻不容緩。」

作者是外務副會長。| The author is Vice-President (External) of HKUSU.


Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion 何藹薇

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

何藹薇:減收非本地生有損國際化優勢

「香港大學素來以國際化自居,調低非本地生對香港大學的優勢會有負面的影響,損害其競爭力。

……這些非本地生在香港大學畢業後可在香港工作一年,及後其公司可為他們申請繼續留港工作。作為香港首屈一指的學府,香港大學吸納優才來港能提升人力資源的質素。

……針對聯招學位不足,大學應審慎考慮非聯招收生,而非盲目減低非本地生的收生人數。香港大學減低非本地生的限額雖能增加學位,但卻令其失去國際化的優勢。」

作者是經濟及工商管理學會代表。| The author is Representative of Business and Economics Association. 


Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion Chen Sin Yee

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

Chen Sin Yee: HKU Should Refine Campus Supporting Services

“HKU is not yet ready to accommodate the large number of non-local students in its campus.… The University should not blindly increase the admission of non-local students without truly catering their needs which accompany with the increase in admission; nor should it overlook the cries of the locals which therefore arise. To remain as one of the top Universities and to maintain the high standard of education and research, HKU should first focus on its refinement of campus supporting services before it admits more non-local students. ”

作者是文化聯會代表二。| The author is Representative of Cultural Association II.

Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion 翁健鳴

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

翁健鳴:不應踏回頭路

「現時平均每七名學生就有一位非本地生,作為一家國際級的大學有此比例實不過份,更可以為校園多添外國氣息。按
此比例,非本地生的社群於港大並不會因過小以致於被忽略,在港大校園生活的每個點滴,不論在學術或課外活動上,都可尋得到海外同學的身影,增加了本地生於日常與不同文化背景人士交流的機會。

……香港大學作為頂尖大學,想入讀的人多如繁星,要抽撥部份港大學位予非本地生當然是本地生所不願看到的,但此舉卻是香港大學力保一流地位的必要方法。……香港大學非本地生的配額無需減少,不然便踏上回頭路。」


作者是文化聯會會長。| The author is President of Cultural Association.


Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion Laurence Tang

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

Laurence Tang: Raise Tuition Fee of Non-local Students is Better Way

“Only 4% of non-local students are under the intake quota. This will not cause direct competition between local and non-local students… it is fair to give 20% of intake quota for non-local students to ensure the cultural diversity in HKU. The way to help local students to enjoy tertiary education in Hong Kong is to increase the total intake quota subsidized by UGC.

The way to solve the current phenomenon is to raise the tuition fee of non-local students rather than cutting the maximum intake quota. … HKU still has room to raise our tuition fees to cover the cost paid from the taxpayers… One practical way is to charge different tuition fee for different courses according to their costs.

… It is not a healthy situation for an international university like HKU to reducing the maximum intake of non-local students.”

作者是學生會會長。 | The author is President of HKUSU.

Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion Leung Nga Man

評議員意見摘錄 | Extract of Councillors' Opinion

Leung Nga Man: Number of Mainland Students is Unreasonably High

"The number of mainland students in the University of Hong Kong is unreasonably high as they account for more than half of the total number of non-local students which cannot help fulfill the aim of the policy. If the number of the mainland students is reduced, the total number of non-local students would decrease sharply. There is a room for the university to accept more local students. Therefore, the maximum intake of non-local applicants to HKU should be reduced."

作者是出版及宣傳秘書。| The author is Publications and Publicity Secretary.


Full Version of Written Opinions by Council Members:http://issuu.com/hkusucouncil2013/docs/uc13_cm9_ad__working_paper_b1_writt?e=9616810%2F5284895